Two Eagles On A Bad List...
Football Outsiders has released their "All Keeping Choppin' Wood" team for the 2011 NFL season, meant to "honor" players who, as they put it, display "a level of consistent awfulness that undermines the competitiveness of the team, yet, for one reason or another, is tolerated."
"Keep Choppin Wood" is a reference Jack Del Rio's ill fated experiment when he first took over as coach of the Jags.
The mantra, introduced by Del Rio during the 2003 season, was intended to indicate how the team would slowly whittle away the huge obstacles in front of them. Del Rio placed a wooden stump and axe in the Jaguars locker room as a symbol of his rallying cry.
After his teammates had been taking swings at the wood with the axe, Punter Chris Hanson followed suit and ended up seriously wounding his non-kicking foot. Hanson missed the remainder of the 2003 season.
Two Eagles made the list, one a player and one a coach. Casey Matthews, who they called "ridiculously overmatched" made the team at LB and Juan Castillo is the team's defensive coordinator.
Really, though, naming Castillo defensive coordinator because he wanted to coach defense is like naming Santonio Holmes an offensive captain because you want him to show more leadership. It may work out, but you are just asking for trouble.
36 comments
|
1 recs |
Do you like this story?
Comments
Matthews
yeah this guy was over matched , everybody knew he wasnt as good as his brother
L F J
by Daddycrapper on Jan 26, 2012 6:04 PM EST via Android app reply actions
Matthews shouldn’t have been in that spot.
AR should have to wear a Flava Flav necklace until he learns how to manage a clock.
I am the proud target of temper tantrums.
Exactly!!!
If he was brought along properly (not thrown into starting role week 1) we could have seen similar play from Matthews taht we saw the final 4 weeks or so
Flip a coin......when it's in the air you'll know what you're hoping for
by LRaunThaDamaja on Jan 27, 2012 4:00 PM EST up reply actions
Casey Matthews will be a beast at WLB one day. His brother will show him what it takes to be a Pro Bowler
Difficulties mastered are opportunities won.
by TyeWD on Jan 26, 2012 6:53 PM EST via mobile reply actions
As BIBTA alluded to above
Unless his brother shows him how to use a syringe, I don’t think its gonna happen.
Its all about the []_[]
#FirePaulHolmgren
by philiafan14364 on Jan 26, 2012 7:13 PM EST up reply actions
Not happening, ever. If he ever becomes a “beast” I’ll personally change my signature to “I was wrong about Casey Matthews he’s amazing and I’m an idiot”
Last name Ever
First name Greatest
#PayDeSeanJackson
Good move
I think BGN needs to call us on more of our past BS. Although my sig line would be full of stuff like “I think McNabb can still play” and “I really want Brandon Pettigrew in this draft.”
Still waiting for the Eagles to Bring it Home for Jerome.
his brother...
forgot how to play the position this year on that GB pourous defense…
Must have been his year for random drug testing…
by milroyigglesfan on Jan 26, 2012 9:36 PM EST up reply actions
His brother didn't forget how to play
Losing Jenkins was huge for them. Now they just gameplan for Clay. Jenkins was on the other side of the DL for the Packers so they had to plan for both of them. With Jenkins gone, they just had to really worry about Matthews.
That’s also why the Packers secondary looked so bad. They didn’t get any pressure on the QB which no secondary can cover for 4 seconds consistently. Matthews is still a beast for the Packers he just doesn’t have any real help.
by slandog on Jan 27, 2012 12:05 PM EST up reply actions 1 recs
This is unsurprising.
Where is Page on this list? He’s a notable omission.
Matthews is the worst linebacker to have ever started in Eagles green and Castillo is a joke.
God Damn you, Andy Reid.
The fat queen has failed us again. Reid must go.
I think if you lose your job midseason
and quietly go away, they forget about you before they finish these lists.
Jarrad Page running past Fred Jackson as he scored a TD on a perfectly called run blitz this year was really one of the low points.
Still waiting for the Eagles to Bring it Home for Jerome.
I guess I don't "get" it...
if the debacle of the eagles defense ended up with measurable deficiencies besides poor tackling, I’d be on board.
This goofy list sounds like the fashion police getting all catty at the leopard spots on the red carpet.
If you are going to bash us, do it with some gusto. Don’t go the cheap and easy because the media has been doing it all year.
Grow some bal.lz if you are going to troll…
by milroyigglesfan on Jan 26, 2012 9:35 PM EST reply actions
Shocker!
You mean Matthews and Castillo are bums?
Someone call the Inquirer!
by UnclaimedFright on Jan 26, 2012 10:15 PM EST reply actions
I agree with milroy, Casey Matthews and Juan Castillo were put in bad positions with little time to prepare. The media and fans obviously were critical of their play, so now it’s the “cool” thing to do to bash the two guys that showed measurable progress by the end of the year. If you’re going to bash two people on the team at least provide some stats to support your argument.
Difficulties mastered are opportunities won.
by TyeWD on Jan 26, 2012 10:49 PM EST via mobile reply actions
I blame Reid for the Castillo move, and Castillo for the Matthews move.
Formerly macjack09
"truTV is like BET for white folks." - Chuck
"Brian Dawkins is always 100% Eagles related."--macjack09 & BGN Nation
Casey Matthews was put in a bad spot by Castillo. He stepped his game up considerably the last 3 games of the season. Still not starter material but he never should have been put in that position in the first place. Jamar Chaney should have made the list instead for being one of the worst starting middle/inside linebackers in the NFL.
If you are going to pardon Matthews...
…for lack of preparation, you should also be pardoning Chaney. He had a chance to come back this offseason as the starter at MLB…a spot that he clearly earned with his play last year and one that only should have been in question if we picked up a stud veteran MLB. Instead, they took what little time he could have had in training camp at MLB and gave it to Matthews, in effect making TWO unprepared players by moving him to SAM. If you are going to pardon one, you have to pardon them both.
Why do people always think I'm playing the Race Card???
Is it because I'm black???
chaney still had a better idea as to what was expected
I don’t pardon him at all. He the MLB for christ sake. He’s supposed to be able to tackle pretty consistently and call out all the calls. He needs to own up this coming season, in my book it’s make or break for him this year.
By Castillo or Reid/Roseman?
Casey Matthews was put in a bad spot by Castillo.
You all know I’m not a big blame guy, but what exactly were Castillo’s alternatives to Mathews?
Go ahead and think, I’ll wait.
Probably goes on the front office more than the DC who tried to pick the least-bad of several bad options.
Still waiting for the Eagles to Bring it Home for Jerome.
Oh hey that Greg Schiano guy
coaching TB now.
Chopping Wood was his thing too .
Also had a recruiting class and just ditched it.
I wonder if TB would have let him fake it til signing day
But that’s just as dirty and underhanded as all the schools who are going to try to leech Rutgers recruits.
Still waiting for the Eagles to Bring it Home for Jerome.
As AR would say, “It starts me, the HC, there are things we need to address and work on. I just need to do a better job, it’ll get better, just needs to address the situation better”.
The fact that AR, put his trusted OL coach into the DC position is like putting his own job on the line, “We’ll work on the fundamental to put this team in a better position, it’ll get better, we just need to work hard and do our part”.
A first time DC, who saw limited time during the lockout, haven’t had much chance to work with the players. He had to learn from the bottom up, with his DL coach’s scheme in the “wide-nine”. He also had to understand the Hows and Whys of the secondary, i.e. man to man and zone coverages in the nickle and dime formations.
In his haste to find coverage in the middle field, inserted a rookie and hoped it was the answer to plug a huge gaping hole. Early in the season, things were not looking up, and they threw every conceivable rotations they had on the roster. Someone was playing the Mike, obviously too long and still had no inkling what his job in the position was. AR says, “Obviously, I have to do a better job. I need to go and watch the film, we definitely need to work out those mistakes, it’ll get better”.
Into the late season, the players found the chemistry to take it to the next level. With all the rebuilding playing throughout the year, was it worth the coaches and players learning to trust and know where each positions stands?
We all know that every year all of the teams goes into rebuilding after FA and the Drafts. And at times, some teams goes into overhauling mode, some massive and others not as much. The eagles went into a modest overhauling and found their grooves late in the season. I’m interested in how our team will rebuild with the FA and the draft picks this year. Even with all the talents we have in the mix, it’s never a sure thing as good enough is not good enough. This is the NFL, the top, the elites and we have to be the best, the only way there is.
This is an extra insert:
I remember many years ago, as a young kid. There was kind of special game, where Japan played against the University of Hawaii at the old Honolulu stadium. It was a long day for the players from Japan. They had some good players and they played their heart out.
At every positions, it made University of Hawaii players the elites of the game. From the starters down to the third string, there were no match for the visiting team. In the end, they didn’t want to shut them out and allow them to have their first score of the game.
Imagine players from Japan flying around the fields, all day long. Sometimes you would just wonder where they summed up the stamina to keep going. There were a few times, they moved the chain pass the 50 yard line. They were able to make pass completions, but the run game pretty much looks no where above 25 yards at best.
It’s ironic that the last 15 – 20 minutes of the game, the crowd were cheering for Japan. All and all they put a heck of a performance and played through the whole game on what reserve energy they had left in the tank. The game ended with everyone cheering for Japan, and the players waves to the crowd.
All I’m saying is teams can’t have players of every position in the elite categories. In the NFL there are 32 elite teams, where each teams builds individual players at the best of their game. When the season is over, the best players are chosen to go to the Pro Bowl as elites, and the winner of the Conference claims the elites best. Next year, the routine begins once again. The NFL has to be one of the best elite sport, along with NBA, MLB and NHL, fans keep the teams moving. Without the fan base, like the USFL, there would be no elite sports organization.
by EaglesHeat on Jan 27, 2012 4:26 AM EST via mobile reply actions
Oh Matthews...
I think he could have avoided the KCW list (which includes players for both on and off-field buffoonery) with his strong(er) end of year play…until I thought about his passive-aggressive whiny comments about how hard it is to play for Birds fans. Heres a guy who makes some pretty large contributions to blowing games early in the year, and then goes on to troll the fanbase during maybe one of the worst years to do so? Keep choppin’, Casey…
Me: "The NFC East is like a bastard cross of rock, paper, scissors and the card game war-good luck trying to figure out who has the advantage on a given Sunday"
A Friend: "But the NFC East has 4 teams. Rock, paper, scissors only has 3!"
Me: "Yeah, you're right. Lets just say if the Eagles are rock, the 'Boys are scissors, and the Giants are paper, picking the Redskins is like being an amputee."
by StoneColeKiller58 on Jan 27, 2012 10:23 AM EST reply actions
a level of consistent awfulness that undermines the competitiveness of the team, yet, for one reason or another, is tolerated.
And yet Castillo wasn’t that. He got better by the end of the year, and actually improved the competitiveness of the team.
Say want you want about his long term prospectives, but to say that about him is just stupid.
2011 New York Giants- Worst NFC Champs Ever
BOB
These two were placed in positions to fail by a much higher power.
by andyreidswaistline on Jan 27, 2012 10:03 PM EST reply actions

by 































