What's left to do? - Part 3, The Season Rises
Now that the Philadelphia Eagles have something resembling a roster, it's time for my last blast of negativity and worrying before the opener next Sunday. While the roster will probably change after Saturday it is pretty unlikely to do so immediately, meaning the current roster will be the one that faces the Rams. As such, a To-Do list no longer really applies. But as is the case with every team that ever played the game, there are concerns. Let's dwell on them, shall we?
**UPDATE**: So naturally within 12 hours of my stating the Eagles won't change the roster or starting lineup until next week, they re-sign Joselio Hanson, cut Trevard Lindley to make room, and indicate that Kyle DeVan will start over Danny Watkins. Clearly, they did it just to make me look stupid. Well, the joke's on them, I don't need help for that!
(In case you're interested in reading them, parts One and Two in this series are still available)
Worry List:- Offensive line
- Juan Castillo
- Linebackers
- Kickers
- Michael Vick
- Safeties
- Fullback
My Thoughts:
- OL - The number one concern for the Eagles going in to the regular season has to be the offensive line. Aside from Jason Peters, the line is entirely different than last years. Given that last year's line wasn't ideal, this by itself is not a bad thing. New coach Howard Mudd's reputation is certainly grounds for hope as well. Unfortunately, the Eagles are starting a line in Week 1 that has never played in a game together. They are starting a line with a former backup the Bengals let go at left guard, a right tackle that has been playing left guard almost exclusively for over 5 years, and two rookies who struggled in the preseason. Yes, PFF has a major man-crush on Evan Mathis and the Bengals are worse at evaluating and retaining talent than I am at retaining beer in my fridge. Yes, Todd Herremans is a talented guy who played tackle in college and drives the Mystery Mobile. And yes, those two rookies were selected to start over veterans by one of the most highly respected position coaches in the league. I'm still worried. You're still worried. And Michael Vick probably bought a diamond-encrusted MedicAlert bracelet on the down-low by now.
**UPDATE**: Two rookies won't be starting, as Kyle DeVan will start over Danny Watkins at RG. Much like Mathis, DeVan is a player that a team with offensive line problems decided to cut. - Castillo - No matter the positive impression people got during the preseason, he has to be on this list. We all know his story, so I'll skip the rehash. Can he call plays? Can he make adjustments? Can he build a defense? Can he avoid lingering brain trauma from head-butting his helmeted players?
via i.imgur.com
- LBs - Everyone was expecting the Eagles to pick up a veteran backup for MLB. Then again, everyone was expecting the Eagles to name a defensive coach as defensive coordinator. Sure, they might pick someone up after the magic Saturday cheapness deadline. But for one game at least, the starting lineup will be Moise Fokou, Jamar Chaney, and Casey Matthews. Recently-resigned 26 year-old backup LB Akeem Jordan has more NFL experience than all three starters combined, in addition to his confusing and possibly telling Twitter account name.
- Kickers - In what seems to be a burgeoning theme, the problem here is inexperience. Most of the linebackers have at least played in a regular season NFL game. The same cannot be said for the kickers. Chas Henry and Alex Henery, the Law Firm of Henry and Henery, were the best college kickers available this offseason. Unfortunately, young kickers tend to struggle. While Henry's punts in the preseason have been acceptable, Henery has struggled with consistency. In the final preseason game Henery went 1/2, missing a 43-yarder on the first drive. While he later connected on a 49-yard FG, that was against third-string goalposts.
- Vick - Here we enter the second tier of worry. These are concerns I have that are fairly likely to be at least partially groundless. They still exist though, and a perfect example is the play of Michael Vick. At times last year he looked incredible, quite possibly the best quarterback in the league. Then at some point last season, he fell back to Earth from Starship 7. In his last two starts in 2010 (MIN and the playoff game) his averaged QB rating was 77, including 4 turnovers and a below-60% completion percentage. He hasn't looked better in the preseason, either, averaging 52.8% completion, a 4 to 1 turnover-to-TD ratio, and a QB rating of 45.9. Sure, a lot of this can be blamed on the offensive line and other factors. I also expect Vick to play better in the regular season than the preseason. My worry remains, though, that last season was a one-shot deal, and Vick will struggle before getting hurt early and replaced by Vince Young, who plays lights-out and seals up the starting job and a big new contract next year... Nah, never happen.
- Safeties - See above re: Linebackers. Two second-year players, a rookie, and a journeyman who had less value to the Patriots than the recently released Brandon Meriweather. I don't even count Colt Anderson, since he exists on the roster solely to keep special teams coach Bobby April from committing seppuku. It looks like last year's 2nd round pick Nate Allen won't be starting, due to lingering knee problems, and this year's 2nd round pick Jaiquawn Jarrett has made exactly no impression whatsoever in the preseason. The sole bright side has been overachieving 7th rounder Kurt Coleman. It wouldn't surprise me at all if the Eagles attempt to confuse Rams safety Quintin Mikell by sneaking one of his old green and white uniforms into his locker.
- Fullback - I hadn't given this position much thought recently. Sure, the Eagles drafted Stanley Havili, but that was in the 7th round. He was 14 spots from going undrafted. Despite the Eagles' recent and somewhat bizarre success with 7th round picks, I didn't expect much to come from it. In the past week, however, the Eagles have done everything but put an ad on Craigslist for a fullback, "no experience necessary." After failing to claim Jerome Felton and Chris Gronkowski off waivers, last year's starter Owen Schmitt is probably ready to knock himself out with excitement for the Eagles organization. The moves make sense, in that Schmitt has never been an exceptional blocker or runner in the NFL, but it seems pretty clear they miss what Leonard Weaver brought to the offense.
Your thoughts?
25 comments
|
0 recs |
Do you like this story?
Comments
I don’t think its fair to call henrey inconsistent. He missed one FG.
"Get 'Em"
by FlyEagles15 on Sep 7, 2011 2:16 AM EDT via mobile reply actions
In the preseason
But I was including reports from training camp. I agree it’s not fair to call him inconsistent yet, and he’s 4 for 5 in the preseason. Most of those were short kicks, though. He’s 1 for 2 in 40+ yard kicks.
Incredibly small sample size, true, but rookie FG kickers do usually struggle.
Oh ok. Yeah I remember hearing that too that he was inconsistent in training camp. But youre right, preseason wasn’t enough to really judge him on. I personally think that he will be fine this year… A few bumps in the road, but hopefully nothing to worry about.
On a side note, did u see when chas couldn’t handle the hold on that field goal during the jets game? And the announcers were saying it was a fake FG attempt. I was laughing my ass off. Those guys didn’t have a clue what the hell was going on that entire game.
"Get 'Em"
by FlyEagles15 on Sep 7, 2011 2:41 AM EDT via mobile up reply actions
We were spoiled by Akers though
It’s been like 10 years since a FG kicker was something we had to worry about.
Couldn’t stand the announcers in the Jets game. They were constantly getting things wrong. Plus, Jets homerism is pathetic and lame, while Eagles homerism is wonderful and pure.
Lol But all kickers miss FG's in training camps
Regardless of some of your hair on fire observations, good job on the posts. It reflects you put some time into it.
Cheers
" I don't know if I prefer Astroturf to grass. I never smoked Astroturf." - Joe Namath
by stopyourcrying on Sep 7, 2011 10:24 AM EDT up reply actions
Thanks, I did
Most of the time was spent re-editing though. I think I might have a mild case of OCD.
Of course kickers miss. But as I said in the other comment, we’re not used to being annoyed with a kicker because we had Akers for over a decade. Henery will probably struggle to some degree, and people will go absolutely crazy.
One could make an argument that week 1 vs the Rams will be one of the biggest challenges for Philly this year. Stephen Jackson is one of the most physical runners in the game when you add in Wash’s wide 9 it’s going to be a big time test for our LBs & Safeties.
I want to see if Castillo will stack the box on 1st & 2nd down and, put those corners on an island begging them to throw the ball.
We all know that Andy will not stray away from his 60-40 pass run. I would love to see DeSean deep as the first offensive play of the game. Back those safeties up get them playing 20+ yards off the line of scrimmage early than lean on the run & short passing game till they come back to the box and, burn them with another DeSean deep.
"Learning to eat soup with a knife"
I was reading Turf Show Times
And they were talking about signing Hanson due to their issues at corner.
They may match up well in terms of their D-line on our O-line, but if Vick can buy enough time and the WRs aren’t rusty, they can do some damage.
rec
Well written and unbiased. AND they are all concerns. Unless you prescribe to blind faith.
I am the only one to pick Vick as my biggest worry. I only picked him because if doesn’t play as a top 4 QB this team won’t be good.
1. We throw the ball a ton.
2. He can overcome line deficiencies when his on his “A” game.
3. He can take pressure off our run “D” if we’re putting up points fast.
Joe Banner is Evil Banners father. Kinda like Luke and Darth Vader.
Juan Castillo switching from the offensive line coach to Defensive coordinator is soooo dumb it might just work.
Our defense will not be a top 10 defense this year.
committed your handle
to memory. I know you blog with your brain and not your heart. Double rec.
Joe Banner is Evil Banners father. Kinda like Luke and Darth Vader.
Juan Castillo switching from the offensive line coach to Defensive coordinator is soooo dumb it might just work.
Our defense will not be a top 10 defense this year.
by MightyJoeBanner on Sep 7, 2011 7:27 AM EDT up reply actions
Thanks, appreciate it
Vick could have been #1 on my list, due to the importance of his position to this team. Eagles are a passing team, not running or defense, and QB struggles could kill the season. Even a regression to a somewhat slower Atlanta Vick would not be good.
I don’t expect him to fail, but it’s always possible, and the NFL is full of former one-year wonders.
I agree with you.
I would add Desean’s contract to this list. I just have a feeling that he will half ass it being scared of injury without his payday.
Astra Inclinant, Non Necessitant
Didn't think of that
But it’s possible.
Of course, how much more can he really half-ass it than he already does? Frightening thought.
My reaction:
Like I said above…great Post. Very well-written and unbiased. And all concerns are fair and concerns that any Eagles’ fan should have this season if they are not drinking the Midnight Green Kool-Aid.
1. I agree that no matter the extensive experience of the OL coach, the starting lineup not playing a game together until Week 1 of the regular season is a concern. For years, AR has preached the importance of continuity at that position making it impossible for me to remove that thought from my mind now.
2. I do share with some of the anxiety towards Castillo in his first NFL season as a defensive coordinator. However, at one point or another, all DCs were in their first NFL season as DCoordinators. As someone who left his previous career because he was told “We know that you would do a great job, but we can’t make you a department head without management experience” and then promptly went out and hired someone with management experience who came in and fucked up everything, I can say that I am probably somewhat biased in my optimism. However, I do acknowledge the chance of this not being a successful outcome as higher than the chance that it will.
3. The linebackers are a group that will be HEAVILY under my eye in Week 1. And with Stephen Jackson on the other sideline, for good reason. The biggest problem I have here is the team did not have to choose to give the job to a rookie 4th round pick without even providing any competition. I am all for handing the job over to a first round pick…and I am always for allowing a rookie to beat out a veteran for a position if he can, but I am never on board with just handing a job to anyone picked 3rd round or lower that isn’t a running back. Also, I had extreme confidence in Chaney and felt like he was the MLB of future. With the explanation of the SAM position in this new offense, I don’t mind him being moved there as much anymore, though…but would have preferred a veteran middle linebacker instead.
4. I’m not too worried about either kicker. Pressure is pressure and these kids have performed under pressure extensively already in the big time football schools they played for. I liked what Rocca did last year, but don’t have a problem replacing him or Akers with rookies. Especially given Akers final performance as an Eagle. We lost that game by the total of his missed FGs.
5. I don’t think Vick will be a problem. While i think it is a longshot for him to have the amount of success he had last year, he will easily be a top 10 QB in this offense, which is plenty good enough with how stingy our defense should be. Keep turnovers and injuries down and slide for goodness sake and he’ll be fine.
6. I think you overlooked a player that we will look back on this season and attribute a lot of success to. Jarrad Page is going to be a great addition to this team, IMO. I like Nate a whole lot, but I think Page is what Nate would be if he was juicing. Natural instincts for the position and the physical tools to both stay with and pop anyone on the field. On the other side, I love that Coleman makes the tackles, but hate that he has too. I hope to see something out of Jarrett that warrants that high of a pick, but think Coleman can fill in in the meanwhile.
7. I have been tooting the “replace Schmitt” horn for about 9 months now so it doesn’t surprise me one bit when I hear the Eagles looking for someone, ANYONE (it appears) to replace him. He is adequate in pass receptions and even pass blocks ok when asked, but he is a subpar fullback when it comes to run blocking. Fortunately we ran the ball so few times that his deficiencies were not that glaring, even allowing him to make the pro bowl, but obviously the team saw the same thing on tape that I did, which is why Havilli was drafted and we failed to pick up the two FBs on waivers. I would actually bump this concern up to number 4.
Great post man.
I-C-Y-U-H8-ME
Thanks
1) Now that DeVan is starting over Watkins, continuity is even worse than when I wrote the post, though the experience is better. Really makes you wonder why a 26-year old 1st round pick is struggling so much, while a 6th round pick is still starting at center. The hope is that continuity is overrated, and Vick can buy enough time dancing around to let the OL gel.
2) Fortunately, we had McD as DC between JJ and Castillo. Lowered expectations a lot.
3) Agreed. I’d be a lot more comfortable if Matthews had beaten out even a poor veteran MLB for the job. Good that he got the extra reps, but there was no competition.
4) No, we lost the GB game because their defense was better than the offense. The Eagles couldn’t score a TD until the second half. Akers didn’t help, but he’s not why they lost. And before that game he was really reliable for over 10 years.
5) Well he’ll have more turnovers than last year, that was flukey. It’s also possible he’ll be more consistent. If the O-line can gel and play even adequately, he won’t be tempted to take off and regress to Atlanta Vick so much.
6) I didn’t overlook Page, I just really haven’t seen much from him bad or good. If Nate Allen wasn’t still playing hurt, would he be starting?
7) I didn’t have this concern higher because the Eagles don’t really use a standard fullback much. They can live with mediocre blocking if the FB can catch and run the ball. Schmitt can catch the ball, but never runs in the NFL. And who knows, maybe the fact they tried to replace him means they intend to run the ball more this year due to the shaky O-line. Hope springs eternal and all that.
1) DeVan over Watkins is pretty telling. I have been especially critical for a team always worried about players’ age picking a 26 year old rookie in the first round, but now to see him not starting Week 1 over a guy who just got a locker and playbook is really tough to swallow.
2. There’s not much worse than lowered expectations.
4. Notice I didn’t say we lost the game because of Akers. I said we lost it by the combined amount of his FG misses. There’s a difference. Yes he was a great kicker for us for a decade…but truth is still truth.
5. Agreed that the turnover number was flukey. And even in this offense, the explosiveness probably was a bit too.
6. If Nate Allen was not hurt, he wouldn’t be on the team. That being said, if Kevin Kolb didn’t get “hurt”, Vick might be in Arizona. Doesn’t mean Vick’s presence isn’t a good thing for our team.
7. Hope in one hand and sh…aahhhhhhhh, you know the saying. lol
I-C-Y-U-H8-ME
You eat crayons
Joe Banner is Evil Banners father. Kinda like Luke and Darth Vader.
Juan Castillo switching from the offensive line coach to Defensive coordinator is soooo dumb it might just work.
Our defense will not be a top 10 defense this year.
by MightyJoeBanner on Sep 7, 2011 8:58 PM EDT up reply actions
it is
i have to go to the butcher. I ate ieatcrayons’ last night for dinner. Threw it on the barbie with the shrimp and drank a fosters. I had to eat a lot of shrimp to fill up.
Joe Banner is Evil Banners father. Kinda like Luke and Darth Vader.
Juan Castillo switching from the offensive line coach to Defensive coordinator is soooo dumb it might just work.
Our defense will not be a top 10 defense this year.
by MightyJoeBanner on Sep 8, 2011 7:24 AM EDT up reply actions
Jeffrey Damer? I thought you were dead…
"What THE FUCK is a tomato pie?" - Ralf E Chubbs
Never call a Phillies, Eagles, Flyers or Sixers fans, a band-wagoner. It is disrespectful. We have suffered agony through the years. Philadelphians should be jovial for their teams' success.
by chillyphilly on Sep 9, 2011 12:45 AM EDT up reply actions

by 






























