Kolb: Gets to throw to Fitzgerald, Beanie wells and co in the backfield. Not a great Arizona defense. So So Oline.
Mcnabb: No sidney rice---one migraine plaqued wide receiver who is very good when he doesnt have Migraines. Adrian beast Peterson...Good TE--decent O line and a pretty good defense(in comparison).
Im going with Mcnabb---he has a lot to prove and I think he has a decent year left in him. Kolb I think at this point is the superior talent, but the team around him isnt as strong.