Grading the 2010 Eagles Draft
I've heard a lot of people on BGN wondering if anyone is going to attempt to grade our 2010 Draft now that everyone is grading our 2011 class. I know some people are probably saying it's too early but if we can grade our class less than 24 hours after the draft, I think one year is plenty of time to pass judgments.
Round 1 pick 13- Brandon Graham DE Michigan- B-
His ACL injury at the end of 2010 really hurts his grade. Had a good rookie season but not great. Numbers weren't great, but he got after the quarterback and showed a lot of promise. We won't really know how good he will be until the 2012 season, when he has a full year to recover from his injury, though he should see plenty of time this season.
Round 2 pick 5- Nate Allen FS South Florida- A
Bottom line, we got a starter at the most important position on our defense for the next 10+ years. Also suffered a season ending injury but should be 100% by the beginning season.
Round 3 pick 22- Daniel Te'o Nesheim DE Washington- C+
Okay pick for the third round, but don't really know what to expect from him especially with Coach Wash leading our DL now. Labeled as a high motor guy, but needs to improve his pass rush moves. With Graham recovering from a major injury and Jaqua Parker nearing the end, this is a make it or break it year for DTO with plenty of opportunities.
Round 4 pick 7- Trevard Lindley CB Kentucky- B
Didn't start as an outside corner, but didn't get an opportunity from McD. A lot of potential and proved he can stay healthy which he really didn't show his final two season at Kentucky. Did play as a nickelback in place of Hanson when he started for injured Asante. Good grade because he has potential to be a starting corner for years to come, good value in the 4th.
Round 4 pick 23- Kennan Clayton LB Oklahoma- A
He is undersized and just supposed to be a special teams or nickel LB. I totally disagree, I think he will be our WLB this season right away. Tons of speed and showed a ton of potential againist dallas in week 17 where he got the opportunity to cover pro bowl tight end Jason Whitten and was outstanding. We will see what happens with Clayton in 2011, but I see great things for him in 2011. Great value.
Round 4 pick 24- Mike Kafka QB Northwestern- C+
Probably the toughest pick to grade, the QB position usually is after one season. Hear a lot of high praise from the coaches about Kafka and he even got trade offers for him. I think he is a year away from being a reliable backup, but looks like a good fit in our offense. Not all our QB's have to be track stars despite popular belief.
Round 4 pick 27- Clay Harbor TE Missouri State- B-
Not really a big fan of Harbor but he has some potential. Needs to work on hands and really needs to improve his blocking skills. We wouldn't have to use Celek and Harbor so much as blocker if we could sign a blocking tight end, but that seems to be at the very bottom of this team's priorities. Good potential for Harbor as our #2 tight end, thanks for this pick dallas.
Round 5 pick 3- Ricky Sapp DE/LB/? Clemson- B-
He is a tweener with potential to be a good roation pass rusher, especially for Wash. He was coming off an injury in college so we knew coming in 2011 would be his true rookie season. Everything I hear from the coaches and from Ricky Sapp himself, it sounds like rehab is going great. If he bombs out, it's a wasted 5th round pick. If he can get a few sacks and a lot of pressures as a rotation/nickel DE this is a great pick and absolute steal. I gave it a B- because of the value and potential, can't really grade Sapp on what he has done for us.
Round 5 pick 28- Riley Cooper WR Florida- A-
Late 5th round pick is our 4th wideout and a solid special teams player with potential. Good size and athleticsm, looking to contribute in the redzone. If Michael Vick doesn't underthow him in the playoffs last year, this pick is a A++++++++. Love his potential, size and special teams ability. Great value nearly in the 6th round.
Round 6 pick 31- Charles Scott RB LSU- F F
Another attempt to improve our short yardage/redzone woes. It failed before it had a shot to succeed. That gets an F. This pick also get's an F because we got Jorrick Calvin and he hurt us more than he helped us in the return game or special teams in general.
Round 7 pick 13- Jamar Chaney LB Mississippi State- A+
Our 2011 starting MLB or maybe WLB was a 2010 7th round draft pick. Good size at MLB and great speed, should hold his position down for years to come or into he gets seriously hurt. Seems to be a theme of this rookie class.(Nate Allen, Brandon Graham, Jeff Owens)
Round 7 pick 36(compensatory)- Jeff Owens DT Georiga- D
Didn't make team right away but stuck it out on practice squad and got playing time due to injuries, until he hurt himself severly in that same game. Good value here but bad grade because he doesn''t fit in with Coach Wash and will be cut before week 1.
Round 7 pick 37(compensatory)- Kurt Coleman S Ohio State- A+
Saw time at FS when Nate Allen went down. WIllbe our third safety with the ability to play either SS or FS in a reserve role and in certain packages on the field with Allen and Jarrett. Also a good special teams player.
Overall Draft Grade- A-
A lot of good values here, we have 4 starters here going into 2011 depending on injuries. Kafka should be our backup QB either this season or next season. Kurt will be a key reserve in our secondary. Trevard should take over for Asante eventually. Riley will see more production in 2011, tons of opportunites to prove himself. Ricky Sapp should be a good rotation guy maybe even switch to LB if need be. We had 13 picks and 11 of them saw action and 12 could in 2011. I think we got 11 good players that could be a part of this team for a while and at least 2 future pro bowlers.
10 comments
|
0 recs |
Do you like this story?
Comments
I dont know.
How do you do your letter grades. Because all your grades seem really high to me.
I look at a grading system this way.
Ratings
1) A- Pro bowler/Great Starter
2) B – Starter
3) C – Bench Guy
4) D- Just taken up a roster spot
5) F- How in the fuck is he on the team/ Thank god he isnt on the fucking team any more.
well it all depends on what you look at.
If you’re grading them as player that makes perfect sense, but as draft picks I would call a good backup picked in the 5-7 range a great pick, maybe even an A due to expectations.
That being said yeah they are ranked too high, but to get 10+ contribuitors, in any level, on an already playoff caliber team, is really exeptional
Picks are way to high!!
TeO – F
The only B would be Allen
Graham, Chaney, Coleman – C (These guys have promise to becom B or A)
Any special teamers or guys who played less than 100 plays last year – D
Any guy who played less than 50 plays – F
Take the name off the back of the jersey's and reinvent football as a team sport.
"The way I figure it, if my heads gonna pop off it's gonna pop off anyways" - Ellis Hobbs on the possibility of his neck breaking.
I give your perspective an F
Mike Florio, Mark Buerle, Michael Young, Jemele Hill- you have all tried to bring down the Eagles player and fans by way of your awful aritcles and ignorant tweets. Your all in the Axis of Evil.
by MidwesternEaglesfan on May 3, 2011 5:24 PM EDT up reply actions
Honestly
You can’t count Clayton as an A.. He barely touched the field.
Also on Lindley. Yes he got hurt his junior and senior year, however he played his Junior year pretty completely injured and put up numbers to be considered a potential 1st round pick.
Defensive player of the year for 2011 is...
Wild_Eagle!
Yes, Wild_Eagle's infamous reputation did help him get this award. But he shows that he walks the talk that he serves...with his keyboard. Wild_Eagle protects the motherland (BGN) from the evils of noobs, douche-bags, and other assholes. Although he may be crude and unnecessary, all great defenders draws the yellow flag from time to time.
-Awarded by Number5
Other than those issues,
I’d say you did a good job.
Defensive player of the year for 2011 is...
Wild_Eagle!
Yes, Wild_Eagle's infamous reputation did help him get this award. But he shows that he walks the talk that he serves...with his keyboard. Wild_Eagle protects the motherland (BGN) from the evils of noobs, douche-bags, and other assholes. Although he may be crude and unnecessary, all great defenders draws the yellow flag from time to time.
-Awarded by Number5
I really don't like Teo
I seen no potential in him and I see him staying on the roster for another year based on the fact that he was a 3rd round pick. I would rather save that roster spot for a FA like Kiwanuka.
Who's Been Eatin' Hummus?
She passed wind, excused herself, and sponged off in the corner as I sat dazed and confused...

by 
































