Lets say Mcnabb takes the 4-12 redskins and leads them to a 10-6 record and snatches up the last wild card spot. Meanwhile, the Eagles struggle with a bunch of under 27 players (no experience or leadership) to a 6 and 10 record. Kolb turns out to be on a week to week basis about what he was in the New Orleans game and occasionally shows flashes of being really good(KC game) but only against weak competition.
On top of this the Skins beat down the Eagles...TWICE.
Would this trade then still be the best move for the franchise ?
I lean towards yes myself. Unless Kolb is an absolute bust who cant handle being the man(AJ Feeley anyone ? )
I would say it was still the right move. Thoughts ?