This supposed trade offer with McNabb and Sheldog/Asante for Nnamdi Something I can't spell, makes me think that this would be the dumbest thing we could do, hell, I'd prefer a 3rd rounder for McNabb over that trade.

My thoughts were, let's say the Eagles got this offer, what counter would you make, a fair move of course.

Here's mine:
1) McNabb, Sheldon Brown and a 4th for Nnamdi What's his name, Kirk Morrison 

2) McNabb, Sheldon Brown and a 5th for Nnamdi and a 2nd and a 4th. Which would allow us to offer Kirk a contract (which we hope we try to do none the less)