Could Brandon Marshall End Up in the NFC East?
By now, the news is widespread that wide receiver Brandon Marshall has asked the Denver Broncos for a trade. As usual, rumors have sprung up that the Eagles would be interested in acquiring a "true #1 wide receiver." Personally, I think Marshall's chances of becoming an Eagle are just about zero. However, there might be some familiar teams interested in him. Here is a look at the who and why:
The Dallas Cowboys:
Since the departure of Terrell Owens to Buffalo, questions have sprung up across the board if Roy Williams can take his place effectively. The numbers he has put up since being acquired from the Lions have been less than impressive: 2008 - 36 catches, 430 yards, 2 TD. There have been many excuses made for Roy, but the fact remains that he has yet to prove himself as a Cowboy (see the great article by Bye, Dawk :( for more details). While Tony Romo has a great target to throw to in Jason Witten, after Williams, there isn't much to look at on the WR depth chart. Unless someone steps up, more help will be needed.
It might be reasonable to say that the Cowboys would give Marshall a look seeing as it would give them two "big-name" wide receivers to brag about. Marshall's character issues would likely not even be a factor to the front office considering their track record (see Jones, Pacman, Johnson, Tank, and Owens, Terrell).
Likelihood: Medium
The New York Giants:
Much like the Cowboys' situation, the Giants have lost their number one receiver in Plaxico Burress this offseason. Unfortunately for New York, the losses run deeper with the departure of #2 WR Amani Toomer. Although they did draft two high-potential players in Hakeem Nicks and Ramses Barden, the fact remains that these two are rookies and may take some time to blossom into NFL starter quality (fortunately, they can't all be DeSean Jacksons).
Ever since Burress left, New York has been connected to every big-name receiver to hit the market and Brandon Marshall is no different. If the Broncos do decide to put him on the trading block, you can be the Giants will give him a look.
Likelihood: Medium-high
The Washington Redskins:
After their high-profile acquisition of free agent DT Albert Haynesworth and the quarterback rumors surrounding Jason Campbell/Jay Cutler/Mark Sanchez, the Redskins have quickly gained a reputation as an organization who wants to make a big splash this offseason. The NFC East is going to be an extremely hard-fought battle, and the Redskins will definitely need an edge if they hope to make it to the postseason. A one-two punch of Brandon Marshall and Santana Moss would be a force to be reckoned with.
After the departure of aging receiver James Thrash, the only additions to Washington's unremarkable receiving corps this offseason have been former Titan Roydell Williams (who didn't accumulate any stats on '08) and 7th-round compensatory pick Marko Mitchell out of Nevada. Since it looks like they'll have to make do with Campbell as their quarterback this season, upgrading at another offensive skill position could give the Skins that spark that they need to make the playoffs.
Likelihood: Medium
And, just for fun...
The Philadelphia Eagles:
Although the WR position is extremely crowded, the argument could be made that a one-two punch of Marshall and DeSean Jackson would be worth any cost. Personally, I think that with Jackson, Kevin Curtis, Jeremy Maclin, and our great supporting cast that has yet to be finalized, the last thing we need is another troubled, diva wide receiver. We've been down that road. It didn't work out. Give it a rest.
What made me laugh was Bill Williamson's ESPN.com article on potential landing spots for Marshall. Along with the Redskins and Giants, he lists the Eagles with the reasoning:
Marshall has been compared to Terrell Owens on the field - not sure if that's a good thing or a bad thing in the mind of the Eagles.
I think the choice is pretty clear. We've got a nice situation at WR with a big potential for growth. Don't mess with a good thing and stay away from Marshall.
Likelihood: Extremely low
23 comments
|
0 recs |
Do you like this story?
Comments
Probably
Bucs
Miami
Jets? (though i don’t know what they’d give up)
Ravens
Jags
Rams
i agree
I highly doubt they’ll trade him. I mean what’s the chance of them trading Cutler, and then Marshall. If they do though, i think the Ravens will go after him…
www.gogreen4ever.blogspot.com
by xADx GoGreen4Ever on Jun 22, 2009 1:25 PM EDT reply actions 1 recs
Bring him in
Though I doubt we’ll take him, and I think the Eagles are in great position with the current WR talent. I’m actually really stoked about our wideout situation this season. Just for me though, it’d be great to see a second UCF allstar on the roster. Heck, lets get Kevin Smith too… he’d be stellar with an actual zone blocking line. And my team would be the envy of my alumni-knight friends. Just stay away from Culpepper, please.
chicago
why doesnt chicago go and get him .. he would make them an instant superbowl favorite and the team to beat in the nfc
by jack is better than asante on Jun 22, 2009 5:03 PM EDT reply actions
good point… but what else does chicago have to give them? they already gave denver their 2010 1st round pick for cutler. thanks to jerry jones, the asking price for a “true #1 receiver” is 1st and a 3rd, and the bears don’t have that. marshall will probably stay in denver unless a team makes some rediculous offer.
Chicago
Chicago would be a good place for the Broncos to send him, however, they do not have a 1st round pick to give them.
Marshall will most likely stay in Denver.
Questions? Suggestions? Comments?
Email me at: Alec82@gmail.com
Not in the BEast
He’s not coming to the Eagles, although our maddenesque stacked corps would be amazing. You’d basically be eliminating the rest of wr cops, cutis, brown, baskett and maybe avant.
Giants…they’d basically be giving up on all their wr developing into starters. They wouldnt give up high picks before and they won’t give up picks now. Not after drafting Nicks.
Dallas…they’re not gonna give another Roy E. trade. Austin is a nice deep threat.
Wash….devin thomas, malcolm kelly. Not going to wash.
"Eagles fans are a passionate group who love their team," said McNabb, "if not the actual players. It's not like winning a Super Bowl before the first month of the season is the hardest thing they've ever asked of me. That'd be all those times they asked me to go kill myself."
by greenbean#twoOH on Jun 22, 2009 6:24 PM EDT reply actions
best bet is the ravens id say
but id love to give up reggie and that extra 3rd we have for him
by DjacknMacAttack on Jun 22, 2009 7:28 PM EDT reply actions
n ill give em hank, kendra, and the rights to kendras baby
by DjacknMacAttack on Jun 22, 2009 7:29 PM EDT up reply actions 1 recs
And a future baby if we win a super bowl.
"Eagles fans are a passionate group who love their team," said McNabb, "if not the actual players. It's not like winning a Super Bowl before the first month of the season is the hardest thing they've ever asked of me. That'd be all those times they asked me to go kill myself."
by greenbean#twoOH on Jun 22, 2009 8:49 PM EDT up reply actions 1 recs
I don;t know what the Gints would give up
but Id think that the rest of the Beast would be fine if the Giants didn’t get him if they are the most likely ones from the Beast.
He has off-field issues that may end up in a suspension to start, so I doubt given the Cheddar Bob incident that hte Giants get involved.
I mean considering this guy is much more of a talent than Plaxico was at any point in his career, Id think you inquire at least.
I like the idea of going with the youngins tho, but if the price is right I would have no problem at least renting Marshall for one season if that’s what took place. The guy is as talented a WR in the league.
First here is the list of places i think marshall could end up if traded...
Browns, Buc’s, Miami, Redskins, Chargers, 49ers, Bears, Giants, Lions, Jets.
Now out of those the most realistic to me seem to be:
1) Browns(edwards+2-3 for marshall)
2) Chargers(could use a bonafide reciever)
3) Miami(good complement to Ginn and good target for pennington)
4) Redskins(they know how to sell out for a player will all the talent but no work ethic)
Second, I feel that the Eagles are fine, Maclin is a faster version of Boldin (just 2 in shorter and 19lbs lighter) but i see some break away traits in Maclin that I see on boldin(not to mention Maclins only 20 years old). Jackson is out to destroy everyone after his father died(condolences) dedicating your career to someone who was the reason your in the NFL gives you that much more motivation, he is also a rising star. Kevin Curtis is the definition of solid, I would take him just about any day of the week. Avant is a 3rd down wonder, who would want to get rid of that?.. Baskett is well hes just kinda there, he has the speed to be very effective, he has the size and the leaping ability but something just isnt clicking with him right now. Brown has faded as of late, but i really like the promise. And gibson is the “longshot” im pulling for this season, from all reports hes 2nd round material and he has great hands with decent speed, and hes solid, and all reports say he is a hard worker and a good kid.
don't think they'll trade within the division if they even trade
so i doubt it’ll be the chargers
by sports00fan00 on Jun 22, 2009 9:44 PM EDT up reply actions
Eh, its all speculation, but I don’t see any of those 4 happening (assuming the Broncos actually try to deal).
I don’t see them and the Browns swapping their WR issues. Just seems weird and uncommon to me.
Charges have Jackson who’s progressed nicely, and a great receiving TE in Gates. Plus the whole inter-division thing.
Dolphins also have another talented WR in Bess, who’s coming off a solid rookie showing. This is probably the plausible to me however on this list.
’Skins got to have faith in their young WRs, at the very least for one more season. If they both are no shows again, then maybe they try to make a big move at WR in the offseason.
Jets has one of the better shots I feel. If Chicago can give up enough, definitely count them into. I never considered Detriot, but that would be a ridiculous tandem. There or Houston would be fun to watch. I also think the Ravens are very likely option.
On Maclin and Boldin, I personally never liked comparing the two. Maclin is a speed agility and guy, and Boldin is one of the strongest WRs in the league. They may have the same height (which Maclin is only 1/2 an inch shorter by the way) and amount of success, but in my opinion the comparisons end there.
Jackson definitely showed a lot of promise. Let’s hope he doesn’t drop off. Curtis is solid, Avant was a man on 3rd down last seasons. Reggie has a lot of talent, I really wish he wasn’t 28 already. I was a fan of Gibson at WSU, I hope he beats out Baskett (was never a big fan, and hate seeing Kendra all over this website)




















