It’s bad when i’m hoping Mcnabb will play up to par and only see it happen 50% of the time. People are calling HOF for Mcnabb and he has the stats but this CONSTANT inconsistency is the aspect where I wouldn’t mention him with the greats.

Of everybody bashing him.. Yes he is inconsistent we say it every week stop saying it. Everybody knows he is but he gives us the best chance to win. He is one o the best qbs in the league. I agree with ur post. Let him get in a rythm and u won’t see balls at the feet balls over the heads but also u gotta remember time in th pocket helps. On some of those throws last night he was under pressure

i bet vick’s more consistent for god sakes, we always make excuses for his ass.turth is hes always going to be this way.on week he can throw next week his throwin dirt balls.on many plays i was watching there was open receivers but hes riding maclins d right now n stares him down all play and he had plenty of time all game our line was fine

thats why i said fine..not good not brutal..fine.they gave him time on many plays, he didnt use it.

Yet another outing by McNugget that ends in a flop…wish we had a guy like P. Manning….McNabb WILL NOT WIN US A SB!!!

But I don’t have faith in him any more. He’s a good QB, when everything is going well. other than that, mediocre at best. When was the last time he gave us a come from behind victory? With him, it’s always something. Anyway, it’s not hard to be the “best we’ve ever had” or whatever his sycophantic supporters say. All we ever had before him was Jaws….

Not that it’s all his fault, this team is pretty soft in clutch moments: not getting big stops (if you have to go all the way back to the 2 4th downs against the Giants last year, that’s too far), not being able to drive the ball, not winning ANY close games. I blame that on Reid and his coaches. Only Johnson instilled any toughness.

First off, We all can’t have Peyton, Drew, or Tom as our QB.

You are all morons and too blind to realize football is the ultimate TEAM sport. No other sport relies so heavily on Coaching in order to be successful. You know what McNabb has had his entire career….Andy or Marty calling the plays and managing the game.

McNabb is still top 10 despite the inconsistency. How bout some consistently SMART playcalling and time/game management because we are severely lacking in both of those categories. We can’t win a game at the end of the 4th quarter because we suck at calling plays and managing the game. We clearly needed to go for it on 4th down instead of kicking a 50+ yd field go only because we once again squandered our timeouts (2 of which were a complete waste). Even before that, where is the urgency and god damnit, we cannot run for a 3rd a short with either Shady or Westy….Give the fucking ball to Weaver or have McNabb sneak it on 3rd and 4th down. Not enough balance on offense, especially when we’re having success running the ball and moving it slowly, but consistently for 1st downs. It’s ok to score a TD on a 10+ play drive which some fatass coaches will never understand.

I agree with everything you’re saying, but I think this offense could run at higher degree of efficiency (or at least at the same degree) with another QB (for example, 2006 with Garcia)

McNabb doesn’t bring anything to this offense (other than years of experience) that another QB couldn’t bring. The only debatable skills are running ability and arm strength. And we wouldn’t need ridiculous arm strength if Reid & Co. weren’t always trying to set up the kill shot.

But you’re right, the playcallers certainly don’t do him any favors half the time

So everyone thinks im bashing McNabb just to have an excuse. i am from Syracuse. I have been watching McNabb since 1995. I know how he works, I know how he plays. Not trying to say he is the most accurate passer. Not trying to say the offensive line is perfect. But lets be honest. He was drafted for his running ability, and ability to throw on the run. But the Philadelphia organization doesn’t give him opportunities to run.

Did anyone one else think the eagles looked a little out of it? Maybe it was the fact we were playing in primetime or the pressure of playing the cowboys at home for the division lead before 5 road games, but everyone seemed to have lost their confidence. Mcnabb clearly wasn’t jolly old mcnabb and his passes reflect that. There were a lot of tough passes but our receivers dropped a LOT of balls. Without a winning attitude you can’t win games (note loss to Raiders) and last night the Eagles just did not look focused.

you guys keep whining about no timeouts…we needed to challenge both those plays…simple.youd be retarded not to.

not here to talk smack, but I watched that game and, yes, McNabb had a rough night, but how can you guys be blaming him for that loss. I can never understand why Philly hates McNabb so much. You guys had no running game and expect McNabb to sit back there and just win games?