DJax plays with flair – he’s easier to notice.

Both are assets to this team and I hope they continue doing well.

maclin catches long deep passes, whereas jackson catches short passes and just runs past everyone.

jackson does spectacular things spectacularly, maclin does ordinary things well.

Jackson seems to be much more explosive and exciting to watch plus the special teams play Jackson is awesome as a punt returner. Maclin is having a very nice rookie season altho it does seem a tad bit on the quiet side he doesnt get the YAC as Jackson.

I’m pretty pumped that these two are going to be together for the foreseeable future.

When Jackson came in, we didn’t expect him to do what he did. If you were to tell everyone at the beginning at the 2008 season that Jackson would have over 900 rec yards then people would think that you are crazy. But the fact that he did made it hard for Maclin to impress. Because Jackson set the bar high. Even analysts have said “All Maclin has to do is come in and do what Jackson did in 2008.” Easier said then done. Take into consideration these things: 1) Maclin was a first rounder, 2) there has been success among rookie WR here lately (even though some have fallen off the map), and 3) Kevin has been out so we have been expecting Maclin to show up. And he has.

Personally, I have been very impressed with Maclin. People say, “Where is that speed we hear about?” The problem is, Maclin is fast, but in college he was faster than everyone compared to now where he isn’t faster than everyone. He has great speed, just it isn’t as vibrant as it was in college. And of course he’s not Jackson fast. Jackson was faster than everyone in HS, College, and the NFL too (at a 4.29 I hope he would).

He will be a great player in the future. Jackson/Maclin will be the Anquan Boldin/Larry Fitzgerald or Chad Ochocinco/TJ Houshmandzadeh combo of the NFC east for years to come.

Jacksons not really a TD guy. He makes the long plays, but he doesnt get a lot of time in the red zone, so he doesnt score as much. So it should be no suprise that Maclins got more TDs than Jackson did.

Difference was that DeSean Jackson started out extremely fast. First two games with 100 yards? Yeah, that’ll get your attention quickly. Maclin had the big game against the Bucs, but he mostly been a 70 yards guy, a lot less flashy than 100 yards in first two games.

imagine the potency of that offense. DJax, JMac and Shady. i think i just cried a little bit

How the hell does Mark Sanchez make that list?!?

9 TD, 12 INT, 53.3 completion %, 66.5 QB rating.

On what planet is that a good season?

I’m fine w/Maclin. He’s made some dumb rookie mistakes, but he’s contributing as a rookie, and that’s still kind of a new thing for WRs around here.

But yeah, I think he suffers a bit from being the second successful rookie WR. He’s compared to DJ as a rookie instead of Pinkston, Mitchell, Billy McMullen, (or even Reggie Brown, who was pretty good as a rookie.)

We kind of expected DJ to contribute as a kick returner in ’08 and anything he added as WR as a rookie was a bonus. Then, he came out like gangbusters.

jackson, maclin im ready for quite a few super bowl wins in the next 10 years guys

He’s electric on the field, and can take it the distance. There’s nothing flashy about Maclin’s play so far

Call me crazy but in a year or two I think Maclin has the ability to start to have a Torry Holt or Reggie Wayne type career. This kid is the real deal. He’s only 21 and has a long way to go before he reaches his full potential. Once he does that, I think he’ll be a Pro Bowler.

Don’t get me wrong… both receivers are almost definitely future HOFers and Maclin has a lot of work to reach that level, but he has the ability.

Jackson is just downright EXPLOSIVE. He can break a long play every time he touches the ball and I think that’s why there is/was more excitement surrounding Jackson. Jackson also has the ability to be a Pro Bowler (he should be this year), but I’m almost afraid that his ceiling is lower than Maclin’s. Jackson is a boom or bust guy, whereas Maclin is more of just a solid WR that can get you 4-8 catches for 50-100 yards every week.

Regardless, I think they will both be very good WRs for years to come.

I say I love them both EQUALLY. I don’t play favorites.

The notable difference to me is that Jackson hit the ground in full stride during his rookie season. From his very first NFL snap he looked like he had been playing on the NFL level for years. He wasn’t too hard on himself, and he tended not to over-think things.

Maclin, while very impressive, seems like he is still uncomfortable out on the field, especially in the return game. I’ve seen some hesitation from him, and he doesn’t seem to bring that “I know I can do this” swagger that Jackson does. Nevertheless, I give credit where credit is due, and I would say he has exceeded my expectations so far.

They are both good wide receivers, especially for their rookie and sophomore seasons. But one thing in particular has put Maclin above Jackson in my book, his blocking. Simply enough, without Maclin’s blocking, DJax would not have had half of the big plays that he has had this year.

generally low key and humble Maclin

Remember that post back when the Eagles drafted Maclin. The guy said he was at the airport when Jeremy flew in and Jeremy was too good to sign autographs or something. Just thought I would throw in that little gem for the BGN vets who have been members since before the Eagles lost any games.

Jeremy Maclin is a rising star on offense but Jackson already has been burning brightly, ofcourse desean is easier to see he is better recognized.

He isn’t even carrying the ball correctly in that picture.

Run Blocking. Maclin will maul a CB all the way down the field if given the chance. Check out some of our long plays this year, you’ll see it.

Swagger.

Yes, DeSean wins in the “dazzle” category. He’s vocal, he’s embraces the spotlight and he knows he’s the best. I think the most impressive part about it all though, is his sheer size. The guy does literally not weigh in with the stats he’s accumulated (except for his speed). He’s one of those freakish athletes whose sheer, natural athleticism allows him to do what seems nearly impossible at first glance. He scares the shit out of secondaries and special teams coaches. He also matured so quickly (despite what his off field personality might suggest) because he’s stayed so hungry on the field.

Maclin is reserved, humble and disciplined. He blocks when needed, he strives to makes big plays and works for the ball, but he’s still very much a rookie. He’s going to be a workhorse receiver and he’ll have his share of the pie REAL soon. Macs, McCoy and Celek are the future of this offense.

Maclin has 4 TD receptions already in his rookie year.

As for Jackson, thank god that Reggie and Curtis got injured

Jackson made a lot of something out of a whole lot of nothing really last season and deserves a lot of credit for that. The Eagles didn’t have a receiver that demanded double coverage, until Jackson became that guy. Now with everyone rolling coverage toward Jackson, Maclin probably has more opportunities to get open.

came in and was the best thing we’ve seen since TO…that was AWESOME!

Maclin came in and was the best thing we’ve seen since Jackson, who just started last year…so there wasn’t as much excitement

I liked Jackson the day of the draft when he was sitting around with his family in his gray pimped out suit… yeah um… sorry, my mind wondered. Yeah so as I was saying.. Jackson is an explosive player and he is fast. I think the reason Maclin has the stats he has is because other teams are allowing him to be open while double covering Jackson.

BTW – Jackson shoulda-woulda-coulda had 2 TDs… but I won’t remind everyone of that.

I personally think that Maclin will be a better and more consistant receiver. Jackson will have the 8 receptions with 150 yards now and then. But in my opinion Maclin will always be a guy that will get you 5 receptions for 73 yards and a TD every other game. I think his numbers are more impressive then Jackson’s rookie season because he IS a threat in the redzone. The catch against the Bucs, I think it was, was very impressive for a rookie. Just the fact that McNabb looks his way near the goal line is something to talk about.

I know that Jackson is still getting his flashy numbers and for him to get a TD he has to score from about 40 yards out because in the redzone Jackson just gets pushed around or taken out for package reasons.