Five questions with the Giants

This week I traded questions with Ed over at the Giants blog, Big Blue View. Ed also happens to be a contributor to our Yankees site, Pinstripe Alley... So, suffice to say Ed is truly the epitome of all that's evil and wrong.
At least for this week... ;)
So check out his responses after the jump and keep an eye out on Big Blue View for my answers to his queries.
BGN - 3 weeks ago the Giants were riding high as everyone's prohibitive favorite to not only win the NFC east, but probably the whole NFC... Fast forward to today and you're on a 2 game losing streak and everyone is wondering if they're early season success was due to a weak schedule. What is behind the Giants' recent struggles?
BBV - Well, the Saints and the Cardinals are behind the struggles. Two good teams. Actually, in the Saints game the Giants' secondary -- weakened without Kenny Phillips and Aaron Ross -- got exposed. Last week was really a poor offensive performance, probably the first bad one of the season. So, it's been a combination of things. In reality, they just haven't looked like the Giants the past couple of weeks -- not dominant defensively or efficient offensively.
This question may very well be part of the answer to the last question... but the Giants are ranked dead last in the NFL in red zone defense. How is that possible for a unit that's been so good for all these years?
It's really an interesting question. I know Tom Coughlin talked about it this week, and he doesn't have an answer. It really comes down to this -- the Giants are No. 1 in the league on defense in terms of yards allowed per game at 262. But, they really have not been that good. The better teams have been able to exploit the Giants weaknesses. First and foremost that means finding safety C.C. Brown -- Phillips' replacement -- and throwing the ball at him. He is horrific in coverage, if you can call what he does coverage. Of more concern, though, is the defensive line. The Giants are trying to pressure with four quite often, and that group is under-achieving. So, I don't think the problem is specific to the red zone. I think the red zone numbers show you that this defense has not been as dominant as its reputation, and ranking, might lead you to believe.
Let's stick with that Red Zone theme... The Giants offense is 27th in the league in red zone efficiency. It seems like all too often they settle for 3 points when they get inside the 20. What do you put that on?
A combination of things, I think. The wide receivers are still young and inexperienced. I think there have probably been a couple of miscommunications. The Giants also have more of a finesse offensive line that likes to pull and lead block, not go straight ahead. That's tough on the goal line. Thirdly, most Giants fans will answer this question by screaming that offensive coordinator Kevin Gilbride is an idiot. I will say that I think the Giants need to make better use of some of their weapons on the goal line, like big receivers Kevin Boss and Hakeem Nicks, and The Beast, Brandon Jacobs.
With all the injuries in the Giants secondary and the Eagles offense relying almost entirely on big plays through the air this year, do you see that as a mismatch?
Not necessarily a mismatch. There is really only one weak spot in the secondary -- injuries or no injuries. That weak spot, as I mentioned before, is C.C. Brown. He is a huge hitter who tackles well and plays the run well. He couldn't cover me, though, and I'm 49 years old and I've torn by Achilles tendon twice. The key for the Giants is to protect him by getting pressure. Unfortunately, they really haven't been getting to the quarterback enough the past couple of weeks.
This week we learned that Ahmad Bradshaw, who has been great for the Giants this year, has a cracked bone in his foot but is going to continue to try and play. Brandon Jacobs just hasn't been himself this year. Are you worried about Bradshaw's ability to finish this year and is there a reason Jacobs hasn't been the kind of player we've come to expect yet this year?
Sure. I seriously doubt Bradshaw will make it to the end of the year. As hard as he runs and as violently as he cuts and struggles once he is hit, sooner or later that bone is going to give out. Sadly, rest won't heal it. It looks like only surgery will. So, we just watch him and see how long he lasts. Fortunately, we have all been dying to see Danny Ware get a chance to play for the past couple of years. If and when he is called upon to help carry the load we feel confident he can do it. As for Jacobs, I don't think there is anything wrong with him. The past couple of weeks he has run very well (13 carries, 76 yards last week), he just has not had enough opportunities. As the Eagles will, teams have been stuffing eight and nine guys at the line of scrimmage -- and blitzing consistently. Jacobs popped a couple of good runs last week, and hopefully that will continue. Often, though, the Giants are seeing that look at the line of scrimmage and checking to pass.
20 comments
|
0 recs |
Do you like this story?
Comments
Giants defense
I have heard that the loss of Michael Boley has also played a big role in their defensive struggles. Not sure if this is true though.
Giants miss his speed
He was brought in to help alleviate the pass coverage liability in the LB corps… and highly doubtful he plays this week, so Celek and McCoy could both have HUGE games.
As Eagles fans
be thankful his speed is not likely to be out there… it just makes that same old plan of victimizing the LBs of recent years that much easier to do.
Yea
because our we have not had a quick playmaking LB like that in years. In the few games he played he was not only the best LB but one of the best defenders and was down field covering TE’s. We have not had an LB cover a TE since 2000, it was obvious how much of an upgrade he was in 3 games.
In spite of all the concerns raised about our secondary
I think linebacker is our weakest area. Pierce is a good defensive playcaller but he is getting run over these days and can’t keep up with tight ends or running backs over the middle. Danny Clark and Chase Blackburn probably couldn’t even be starters on any of the other good teams in the league. Boley looks like the real deal so we are anxious for his return.
Without great linebacker play it’s no wonder we are so vulnerable on defense in the red zone.
by giant fan since 57 on Nov 1, 2009 4:40 AM EDT up reply actions
were going to miss Westy in this game
I seriously doubt he plays and he KILLS the giants.
Let's get it.
I'd like to know...
whats up with Eli Manning. He hasn’t looked particularly good the past couple of weeks. Then again, I didn’t think he looked all that great against some of the crappy teams he played so what do I know.
Let the beasting begin.
by TransplantedFan on Oct 30, 2009 2:04 PM EDT reply actions
he hasn't looked too good the last two weeks
but prior to that he was second to Peyton in almost every QB category….how is that “not looking great against crappy teams?”
"[The Giants] beat us down. We were beat by a grown-man team, a team we want to be like one day. They came in here and took it to us. Out-manned us, out-gunned us. ... It wasn't even close." - Raheem Morris, 9/27/09
Totally disagree about BBV's view of Brandon Jacobs...
I’ve seen every Giants game so far, and he is far from the player I’ve seen the past 2 years. There’s definitely something wrong there.
Giants D...
No Spags, no blitzes! Is it really a suprise theyre not going after the QB as much this year?
"the epitome of all that's evil and wrong"
I am honored that you think so highly of me, Jason. LOL!!
I love Kevin Boss (who by the way, has the best wiki picture of all time)
but hate the Giants.
"Goals are good. Plans are better." -Ben.
I think what we're finding out
Is that Eli is only a good QB when the Giants are able to get a dominant run game going. Get in his face all day and he throws off the mark… Our Qbs are so similar right now the only difference is McNabb throws ’em low and Eli has them sail over the WRs heads.
We need to make sure they don’t get their run game going and get in Eli’s face… Oh, and our offense has to be consistent………we’ll see, what ha ppens, can’t wait for this game.
E-A-G-L-E-S EAGLES!!!
You could make that statement about any quarterback except maybe Peyton or
Brady. And even Brady seems to be less of a superman these days. I think that an uninspired and predictable game plan coupled with too much reliance on the shotgun has weakened our “run first” philosophy.
Running the ball consistantly as well as play action work much better when the quarterback is over center. It’s a lot harder to pick up the ball when the quarterback is running away from the line. I also believe that defenses have caught on to the quarterback reading the coverage just before the snap and reduced it’s effectiveness with disguises. We would be better off if we just lined up and ran the damn play and saved the shotgun for passing situations. That’s what it was originally designed for.
by giant fan since 57 on Nov 1, 2009 4:50 AM EDT reply actions

by 
















