Bleeding Green Nation: An SB Nation Community

Navigation: Jump to content areas:



Sports blogs for fans, by fans.
Around SBN: Steve McNair Dead - Former NFL QB Shot and Killed


spread the word

Brookover Respectfully Disagrees

In his Sunday morning piece for the Inquirer, Bob Brookover directly contradicts his colleague Rich Hofmann from the Daily News. As I noted yesterday Hoffman acknowledged the way in the NFL today is to throw the football when the running game isn't working.

Today Brookhover maintains:
It's no secret, however, that if something works other teams around the league start to adopt the same plan, and right now the two best teams in the NFL - the New York Giants and Tennessee Titans - are running the football more than they are throwing it.
This statement is rather misleading. It looks at the Giants and Titan's statistics as a whole, but does not consider the situations which enabled them to run so much. Consider their average yards per pass play, the Giants average a full half yard better than the Titans. The Giants offense has no problem moving the ball through the air, whereas the Titans are an average offense in general. The reason the Giants run the ball so much is because they so often have the lead. The reason the Titans run so much is that they don't want to turn the ball over.

The Giants are dominating teams both running and throwing the football, but the Titans are winning with effective game management and creating turnovers. In fact the Giants and Titans are #1 and 2 in the league in turnover margin. It's hard to assume an average value for a turnover - an interception in the end zone is worth more than one that occurs at the 40. But if we suppose about 3.5 points for a turnover than the Giants have benefited to the tune of 35 points from turnovers and the Titans - 45. The Eagles on the other hand have only netted 3.5 points from turnovers and I can point to 3 games which turned on turnovers (Baltimore, Dallas, and Cincinatti) just off of the top of my head.

Brookover reiterates the meme which says that an effective running game is a quarterback's best friend:
There's also the theory that a strong running game makes a decent quarterback good and a good quarterback great.
He quotes Quentin Mikel noting how important the Giant's running game has been to Eli Manning's success this year. He also cites several examples of teams who run more than they throw and suggest that their rushing attacks have helped out their quarterbacks.

The difference between the Eagles and these other teams is that the Eagle's running game is not effective. Against Arizona, the Eagles were able to run the ball because the Cardinals took a player out of the box relative to how many the Eagles had. Rather than offering a "8th man" they offered a 6th. Obviously it'll be easier to run when you've got more blockers then the opposing defense has defenders.

I agree with Hofmann, today is not the day to reinvent the wheel. The Eagles must run the football, but for them to be effective they need to do it out of a pass look. The power running game is something that will have to wait until free agency and the draft. I hope for third and one's sake that they do during the offseason.

0 recs | Comment 2 comments | Share on Facebook Digg!

Story-email Email Printer Print

Comments

Display:

cavortingEagle, I think both you and Rich Hoffman should include in your analysis the fact that the Ravens and Falcons, both teams with rookie QBs, prominently feature the run and are therefore doing quite well this season.

I disagree with your assertion that the Giants are a pass first team that runs primarily when they have the lead. In fact, the Giants passing game works so well because of the running threat they have. And their running threat is as dangerous as it is because of Plaxico Buress. Confused? Let me explain.

What makes it so difficult for the Giants run game to be stopped is because of the threat of Plaxico over the top, requiring one safety from the defense to be held out of the box at all times (at least until now).

Teams have to respect the play-action pass against them, and whenever their passing game is struggling they have this as a go to weapon that essentially always works. Prior to the game against Philly, the Giants had run 88 times on first down, for first place in the NFL in that category. Sounds like a run first team to me.

With Burress gone, watch teams move 8 or 9 into the box to slow down their run game while covering the other receivers one on one on the outside. This takes away the run threat, the Giants become one dimensional and voila! no longer the most feared offense in the NFL.

by Eagles need to run on Dec 7, 2008 4:38 PM EST reply reply actions actions   0 recs

I don't disagree see:

well that was nice
Running the football is an integral part of the game which can not be ignored.

by cavortingEagle on Dec 8, 2008 10:33 AM EST to parent up reply reply actions actions   0 recs

Comments For This Post Are Closed


User Tools

Welcome to the SB Nation blog about Philadelphia Eagles.
Start posting about the Eagles »

Join SB Nation and dive into communities focused on all your favorite teams.

FanPosts

Community blog posts and discussion.

Recommended FanPosts

Greenman2_small
Part 2 of 32 - Dallas Cowboys - Do the Eagles have the potential to be THE dominant team of the next decade?
Greenman2_small
Do the Eagles have the potential to be THE dominant team of the next decade? 32 part series...
1331858627_f97bbd36d2_small
An Eagles Rookie You May Not Know
Greenman2_small
3 things you might not know about our NFC East opponents...

Recent FanPosts

Brak___gyaaar_small
Former MVP McNair found dead
T1_freddie_media_all_small
Pete Prisco's Over and Underrated Players
Lebron1_1__small
Your Second Favorite Team
Nfl_philadelphia_eagles_1_small
Expect Big Things from the Big Kid
Bear-bryant_small
Really interesting series of articles on factors to success
Newaerial_small
First time Fantasy Football player
Eagles_giants_06_002_small
Seven Eagles Destined for Success
C93089635ea6d51006daa92676c6dde8_small
Rookie Free Agents - Diamonds in the Rough?

Post_icon New FanPost All FanPosts Carrot-mini

SPONSORS


Official Partner of Yahoo! Sports