Story of 6 QBs

by NickPampani on Nov 26, 2008 1:12 AM EST

[Note by NickPampani, 11/25/08 9:57 PM PST ]
Ok so with all out QB controversy I have came up with a little comparison. Here is 6 different QB both past and present in which most of them if not all will be Hall of Fame QBs. I took the first 10 years of each of their careers and lined them up against each other.

	Games	Comp.	Att.	Pct.	Yards	YPG	TD	Int
QB1	140	2993	4931	60.7%	34706	247.9	255	155
QB2	123	2424	4132	58.7%	28174	229.05	185	89
QB3	151	3159	5284	59.7%	39502	261.60	300	165
QB4	85	1926	2959	65.1%	24008	282.44	152	100
QB5	130	2524	4517	55.9%	29878	229.83	153	154
QB6	144	2475	4336	57.1%	30216	209.83	158	157

	TD per Game	Int per Game	Sacks	Sacks per Game	Rate	Super Bowl Wins	SB By Retire
QB1	1.82	1.10	299	2.13	77.7	1	NA
QB2	1.50	0.72	316	2.56	85.3	0	NA
QB3	1.98	1.09	153	1.01	88.2	0	0
QB4	1.78	1.17	210	2.47	84.8	1	NA
QB5	1.17	1.18	257	1.97	78.7	0	NA
QB6	1.09	1.09	325	2.25	72.9	0	2

So there are some numbers of 6 very good and very well known QBs but 10 years doesnt mean much. this is a tough game and its all about what you've done for me lately so i have came up with that stat too. here is the last 3 years of each QBs 10 years. so thatis season 8 9 and 10

	Games	Comp.	Att.	Pct.	Yards	YPG	TD	Int
QB1	48	1026	1726	59.4%	12115	252.39	73	62
QB2	35	706	1189	59.4%	8741	249.74	51	23
QB3	48	954	1634	58.4%	11649	242.68	70	40
QB4	26	631	994	63.5%	7507	288.73	44	31
QB5	42	908	1558	58.3%	10678	254.23	53	50
QB6	44	710	1269	55.9%	9021	205.02	38	43

	TD per Game	Int per Game	Sacks	Sacks per Game	Rate
QB1	1.52	1.29	106	2.20	80.2
QB2	1.45	0.65	82	2.34	88.8
QB3	1.45	0.83	70	1.45	84.5
QB4	1.69	1.19	57	2.19	88.3
QB5	1.26	1.19	77	1.83	77.0
QB6	0.86	0.97	124	2.81	73.2

What do you think? who are thes QBs? who do you like? who is overrated? who should be let go from their respective team at that time? who would you trust more to lead the eagles into the next few years of the rebuilding process?

Poll

Who do you like the best for our team?

QB1

3 votes

QB2

12 votes

QB3

10 votes

QB4

8 votes

QB5

0 votes

QB6

1 votes

34 votes | Poll has closed

Tweet Comment 22 comments | 2 recs |

Do you like this story?

Comments

I have to say i am not going to vote in the poll since i know who each quaterback is.

by NickPampani on Nov 26, 2008 1:42 AM EST reply actions

Im gonna have to go ahead and say 1 qb is McNabb. Now I lknow its not 1 or 4…

by Clyde Simmons on Nov 26, 2008 7:55 AM EST reply actions

is qb5 McNabb?

by Clyde Simmons on Nov 26, 2008 7:56 AM EST reply actions

How will these QB’s respond to the harsh Philly media and fans? How many SB rings to they each have? How well do they respond to pressure? Can they play shitty all game, then pull out a win in the 4th quarter? etc??

I know #2 is Don, as he has one of the best TD/Int ratios out there. I have always liked Donovan, but the numbers above are not nearly enough to go on in making a decision.

Honestly, I am not against starting McNabb next year, and retooling for another run. As bad as we have been, we are still not that far off. It would take some big changes though, and I am not sure the current front office would make them.

by captain nodar on Nov 26, 2008 8:23 AM EST reply actions

captain

i have up there how many SB rings each one has. and i do belive all these QB would fair well when handling Philly fans.(1 or 2 might be in question) and to be completely hounest ive seen all 6 handle pressure well

by NickPampani on Nov 26, 2008 9:46 AM EST up reply actions

Nick

My apologies for that, I did not see it.

by captain nodar on Nov 26, 2008 9:56 AM EST up reply actions

no problem. i figured somebody would ask thats why i put it there

by NickPampani on Nov 26, 2008 10:37 AM EST up reply actions

Great post

Can’t wait to see who’s who.

by MJW on Nov 26, 2008 9:18 AM EST reply actions

Agreed! This is a great great post!

an Eagles fan should be an Eagles fan during an 0-16 season

by 700 Level on Nov 26, 2008 12:13 PM EST reply actions

2

doesnt turn the ball over much…completes a good % of passes and doesnt take too man sacks.

by Joe_D on Nov 26, 2008 1:34 PM EST reply actions

QB#2

I’m guessing #2 is McNabb because of the lowest INT rate of any of the QBs. And you’re right… when McNabb is somewhere else, maybe he’ll be appreciated for how good he was in Philly.

There’s no doubt McNabb has talent and that he has good football left in him. I just don’t think it’s here. There’s been too much with the media, fans and now with Reid to continue in this town.

by JJinPA on Nov 26, 2008 6:26 PM EST reply actions

hahaha this is like waiting to open presents on christmas…waiting to see whos who

by phila.eagles on Nov 27, 2008 11:53 AM EST reply actions

ill tell you guys soon

i was waiting on a little more posts and intrest first

by NickPampani on Nov 27, 2008 3:18 PM EST up reply actions

I went 2...

im betting its McNabb too… Low INTs (i hate turnoevers), decent production for TDs (not the worst, but not the best). I didnt like the sack rate though, but that could also be looked at from the Oline.

Look up... get up...Don't ever, ever give up!!

by anuj on Nov 28, 2008 10:37 AM EST reply actions

no

i disagree. only because for the past few years mcnabb tends to hold onto the ball too long and eat the sack instead of throwing it away. This year he has gotten better somewhat, but the O-line throughout his career has always been above avg.

by Joe_D on Nov 28, 2008 4:04 PM EST up reply actions