Bleeding Green Nation: An SB Nation Community

Navigation: Jump to content areas:



Around SBN: The Georgia Bulldogs and the Presidential Election Year Jinx Bar-right-arrows



spread the word

Reid backs McNabb, does McNabb back Reid?

The local peppered Andy Reid with questions about Donovan McNabb in his day after press conference. Should he be replaced? Is it time for Kolb? Is McNabb finished?

"Donovan, for every throw that he didn't make there, he'll get himself back. I know that he has already talked to you (writers covering the game) after the game and put the blame on his back, which quarterbacks do,” Reid said. "He'll continue to fire and get whatever is wrong straightened out and get it right.”

"We'll get through it,” Reid said. "We'll work through it. He'll continue to push. He's a competitive guy. We have to make sure that we are putting him and the receivers, running backs, tight ends, that we're putting them in the right spot in the pass game and that everybody executes. Everybody has had a little piece of it, and we can all do a better job.”

OK fine... But is anyone asking Donovan McNabb if he thinks Andy Reid will "get it right." Does McNabb think Andy Reid is going to "get whatever is wrong straightended out and get it right?"

I'm not writing this an excuse of the play of McNabb on Sunday. We all saw him struggle and it's likely that no matter what offense Reid was running McNabb was still going to be off target and making bad throws that day. Still, his poor play shouldn't cover up the playcalling in the game.

McNabb's poor play shouldn't cover up the fact that the Eagles that the Eagles threw the ball 58 times and ran it 18. It shouldn't cover up the fact that against the 1-8 Bengals the Eagles offense was completely one dimensional and relying on poorly executed trick plays. But when the media does bother to ask about what role Reid might have had in the struggles, he flat out doesn't tell the truth.

"You end up trying to get Brian going is what you are trying to do," Reid said Monday. "With running backs, you try and get it right, and with that we left (Westbrook) in and tried to get it going."

That's just not true. I don't know any other way to say that. Brian Westbrook ran the ball 14 times. Fourteen! When you hand the ball to a guy 14 times you absolutely did not "leave him in and try to get it going." "Just keep firing" only applies to the passing game. If Mcnabb is stuggling Reid he tries to get him going by throwing more. If Westbrook is struggling, the running game is abandoned.

So now we'll endure all these columns where writers say it's time to bench McNabb and start Kevin Kolb... As if that would make any difference. The offense is unsustainable as is. Put whatever QB you like in there, if he's asked to run an offense where we throw 94 times and run 30 the last two games I doubt the results will be much different.

0 recs | Comment 13 comments | Digg!

Read Related

Story-email Email Printer Print

Comments

Display:

Put whatever QB you like in there, if he’s asked to run an offense where we throw 94 times and run 30 the last two games I doubt the results will be much different.

agree…

by Joe_D on Nov 18, 2008 1:02 PM EST   0 recs

Agreed

You ask Peyton Manning or Tom Brady to throw 60 times and it could get ugly. I wish I knew what Donovan was thinking; I wouldn’t be surprised if he’s lost complete confidence in Andy Reid and the play-calling.

by ajay on Nov 18, 2008 1:19 PM EST to parent up   0 recs

I’m pretty sure Tom Brady tossed a lot of balls last year … difference is he threw for running plays, 3, 4, 5 yarders to Welker. McNabb has serious trouble with short passes it’s almost always in the dirt.

"I need to do a better job of putting players in the right position to perennially come up short of expectations"

by Whodie126 on Nov 20, 2008 3:42 PM EST to parent up   0 recs

When McNabb got hurt and missed the last five games of 2006 and Garcia stepped in, Reid handed the playcalling over to Marty Morningweig. The result was a more balanced attack of run vs. pass, and both the running game and the passing game became more effective.

IMO, the WCO is old and tired and too many people have its number. The Bengals expected and practiced to defend the reverse and Andy’s gimmicks have become predictable and ineffective so that even a 1 – 8 team could stop the Bird’s offense.

What we need is a change of approach and attitude. Tom Coughlin successfully did it with the Giants, but I doubt it will happen with Andy. Andy can’t manage his kids, let alone this football team! ! ! As Andy won’t change his tune and will stubbornly cling to what’s not working, it’s up to Lurie to remove him before we suffer through another season of missing the playoffs.

by JJinPA on Nov 18, 2008 3:07 PM EST   0 recs

then why

couldn’t an 8-1 team stop the offense a weak earlier?

by eagleyosh on Nov 18, 2008 7:39 PM EST to parent up   0 recs

I agree that Andy has just stubbornly stuck to his scheme. He has total faith in the system despite the fact that it has become one of the easiest schemes to game plan for. The opponents that know the Eagles best at this point (the NFC East) all managed to stop the Eagles at crucial points in the game because the scheme has gotten too predictable. I think that’s the perfect indicator of a predictable scheme is how you’ve matched up against your divisional opponents. I’m not calling for his head, just some innovation to the scheme.

by chrismchaines on Nov 18, 2008 5:01 PM EST   0 recs

Very well put Jason.

by FuquaManuel on Nov 18, 2008 5:37 PM EST   0 recs

i honestly think Reid is only throwing this much so he doesnt have to take back his comment about “Keep Firing” So until i guess we will “Keeep Firing” until we win….:-/…well until then keep Westbrook off your fantasy team

Fire the Fat One
Fire Andy Reid

by XxBleedGreen5xX on Nov 18, 2008 6:56 PM EST   0 recs

i hope Andy keeps the ball out of McNabb’s hands for one more week…this has to be his worst play calling year yet..his goal line everything stinks. after being embarrassed by the giants, i hope the ravens have something in the tank for the wits and witouts. its a huge game for both teams.

by raven on Nov 18, 2008 7:46 PM EST   0 recs

Reid

Should have been let go after your 3rd NFC championship loss; your team has had a sh!tload of talent; I don’t think it’s as talented nowandays; the front office is good at drafting for talent but doesn’t get the whole concept thing.

Ex; why did they draft a big Blast blocking O-line and then not get a bruising tailback? The Giants use a Wham blocking scheme but still found a twinkle-toed 264lbs to run it. Mcnabb is a great athlete but he hasn’t become a field general. But that’s Reid’s fault. Notice how the ’phins got their shit together after Bill showed up?

Obviously, I’m not a iggles fan, but you guys have suffered a lot, and we need help keeping the cowgirls in the basement every year. Because that is the Prime Directive.

From a Syracuse/Giant fan.

I will now retreat into the bunker as you guys assemble the artillery.

by The Pale Scot on Nov 19, 2008 12:01 PM EST   0 recs

Thanks for the relatively intellegent post...

we’re not really used to that from Giants fans of late

"and with that play the Philadelphia Eagles complete the most improbable run to a Superbowl Crown in NFL history"
-Merrill Reese (February 1, 2009)

by 700 Level on Nov 19, 2008 1:03 PM EST to parent up   0 recs

+1… love the sig btw…

http://www.libertyballers.com

by Remis on Nov 19, 2008 10:03 PM EST to parent up   0 recs

Comments For This Post Are Closed


User Tools

Welcome to the SB Nation blog about Philadelphia Eagles.

FanPosts

Community blog posts and discussion.

Recent FanPosts

Chiliicon_small
Eagles Fans are Class Acts
Avatar_small
Sean McDermott to become Saints new defensive coordinator
Cryto_small
Marvin Harrison
Fp4107philadelphia-eagles-posters_small
Eagles staying or leaving
Small
Eagles/Giants preview: The Why Bother edition
Eagles_v_cards_002_small
Philly Rally Beards
15976_160_small
Nick Cole
Small
enjoy this ride eagle fans
Small
Props to McNabb/Gocong
Believe_-_chad_pennington_small
Polamalu or Reed?

Post_icon New FanPost All FanPosts Carrot-mini


Site Meter